THE CONVERSATIONS
Khalil Abu RayyanSep 8, 2026 · 1h 52m

Catfished by the FBI: “They Wanted Me to Join ISIS For Love”

Apple PodcastsSpotify

Behind the conversation.

Khalil Abu Rayyan was 21 when he was arrested following an FBI investigation into his alleged support for ISIS. He was never charged with terrorism, but received a five-year prison sentence for firearms offenses.

In this episode of Not From Here, Khalil joins us to share his account of the undercover relationship, the investigation, and what happened after his arrest. We also get into the loneliness that preceded it, what his family went through, and the parts of his life he is still trying to rebuild.

In this conversation, we discuss:

His search for belonging as a young Arab American Muslim, and the online activity that attracted the FBI’s attention.

The woman he wanted to marry, their messages, and how he discovered she was undercover.

A year in solitary confinement and the prisoner he credits with saving his life.

Finding faith and Muslim brotherhood inside an American prison.

His father’s prison visits and what it meant to see him cry.

Learning to trust people after release, returning to school, and why he still struggles to forgive himself.

NOT FROM HERE